Home » Sponsored » Pi Speakers » Seven pi questions
Seven pi questions [message #43831] Sun, 01 February 2004 12:46 Go to next message
more is currently offline  more
Messages: 6
Registered: May 2009
Esquire
I'm still trying to sort out whether or not I want to go for eminence delta 15" or jbl 2226 in the seven pi speakers, or if the pi's will even work out for me at all. I'd appreciate any advice, esp. from people who have heard both woofers in similar setups or maybe have a similar setup.

1. Most listening is late night when the family is asleep - probably 90-93db. I know the 4W SET i plan to use will push seven pi's much louder than this, but will they still sound good at a fraction of a watt or do the drivers really need more power to "wake up"?

2. Is the quality difference between the jbl and eminence 15" perceptable at less than a watt or a few watts, or do they really sound the same until you are well over 100db? From what I gather the eminence goes lower but has more distortion and a less refined high end than the jbl - is the difference in quality - bass cutoff aside - really noticeable?

3. I love the magnepan's great imaging, depth and layering of the sounds - so will I hate corner horns? Listening to magnepans is like watching a movie - all the action is between the speakers and the wall behind them (or even much further - sometimes very spooky). This effect isn't always welcome though - I feel like I'm on the outside of a window looking in with magnepans (and pretty much any other decent box speaker setup I've ever heard) and never like I'm in the middle of the action. Placing speakers directly into corners seems a little funny to me but maybe I've been brainwashed with the concept that speakers need to be pulled out into the room - away from rear walls and side walls - to sound best wrt imaging, etc. I know the corner is required to form the bass horn, but is at the expense of imaging, depth, etc.?



Re: Seven pi questions - forgot to add [message #43833 is a reply to message #43831] Sun, 01 February 2004 12:54 Go to previous messageGo to next message
more is currently offline  more
Messages: 6
Registered: May 2009
Esquire
Current system is vertically bi-amped magnepans w/ crossover removed driven by a pair of stereo 35-40W tube amps, passive line-level 6db crossover, tube preamp, and a behringer ultracurve to reduce bass peaks and other conservating tweaks. Room is about 15' x 16' x 8'.

Audition [message #43834 is a reply to message #43833] Sun, 01 February 2004 14:14 Go to previous messageGo to next message
Wayne Parham is currently offline  Wayne Parham
Messages: 18787
Registered: January 2001
Illuminati (33rd Degree)
I think you should audition a pair. That means you'll either need to find someone else's speakers to hear or you'll have to build your own. What part of the planet are you on?

Re: Audition [message #43835 is a reply to message #43834] Sun, 01 February 2004 14:56 Go to previous messageGo to next message
more is currently offline  more
Messages: 6
Registered: May 2009
Esquire
Hi Wayne, I'm right smack in the middle between Milwaukee and Chicago.

Folks near Chicago, Madison or Milwaukee [message #43836 is a reply to message #43835] Sun, 01 February 2004 15:14 Go to previous messageGo to next message
Wayne Parham is currently offline  Wayne Parham
Messages: 18787
Registered: January 2001
Illuminati (33rd Degree)
There are some forum regulars in your area, I think. Illinois and Iowa folks might chime in, and if you're not too far apart and everyone is willing, I think you might be able to arrange a visit.

Horns vs. Maggies (one person's experience) [message #43840 is a reply to message #43831] Mon, 02 February 2004 07:18 Go to previous messageGo to next message
HenryW is currently offline  HenryW
Messages: 44
Registered: May 2009
Baron
As suggested, you should audition to be sure. However, you are pretty spot on to what I heard with my maggies. While they could be extraordinary and and had one of the best 'sweet spot' listening experiences for me, I went back to my horn roots.

There were a couple of reasons for me - First, as picky as horns can be regarding electronic matches, the MAggies were more so. I piddle with too many things and horns give me a bit more freedom. Second, they had such a small sweet spot in my set up (and really changed dramatically when I put my ear above the panel). Horns were much more room 'filling'.

That said - If I had a room that I tuned for one chair I might have to give my vote to the Maggies.

All is IMHO

Ohio has many Pi speaker owners - not close - but worth the trip! [message #43841 is a reply to message #43831] Mon, 02 February 2004 11:10 Go to previous messageGo to next message
spkrman57
Messages: 522
Registered: May 2009
Illuminati (1st Degree)
I am running JBL 2226 (4 PI) and Altec 902 on (650hz/round/wooden Edgarhorns). I am running currently on a ASL Tulip 2A3 amp with 1st order crossover, but have run 3rd order Pi crossover also.

I believe the JBL will be more truthful to the music than the Delta 15's. I'm not saying the Eminence drivers are bad, just that the JBL's are that much better.

I am running the 15" driver with 2 mh coil(should be 1.4mh). I am planning to make a multiple connector so I may use the 1st order for low-power and swap to the 3rd order on the horn for up to 300 watts. They both have their merits.

By the way, for those interested in the 1st order cap i am using, a 4 ufd "oil in can" vintage 1958, rated at 50VDC. Might not be textbook value, but works pretty good in my small room.

Added note: I am using the JBL 3677 cabinets for my 2226, but having the driver towards the top of the cabinet(upside down), not near the bottom where I had it before. The reason being is that I am currently using a Titanic 12" su, and getting the 2226 off the ground cleans up the midrange/midbass.

I am not normally a sub-woofer person, but the price was right from a friend, so will play with it awhile before removing it from the system. Really nice with pipe organ music, but I don't need for my regular listening.


Regards, Ron

Re: Seven pi questions [message #43842 is a reply to message #43831] Mon, 02 February 2004 11:23 Go to previous messageGo to next message
GrantMarshall is currently offline  GrantMarshall
Messages: 77
Registered: May 2009
Viscount

If you want good sound late at night you can't beat a good set of headphones.

That being said the cornerhorns will sound good without a lot of watts. I didn't really like the distortion in the Delta 15 speakers when I had them. (they're in a box in the basement now.)

I have a 3 way cornerhorn which uses a high efficiency mid in a non-horn setup. The imaging is good with this set up. The 4 Pi guys also claim good imaging with low watt systems.

Grant.

Re: Seven pi questions [message #43846 is a reply to message #43842] Mon, 02 February 2004 16:17 Go to previous messageGo to next message
more is currently offline  more
Messages: 6
Registered: May 2009
Esquire
That's a good point but I just can't stand headphones on my head - not an option.

If you can spare a few mins. could you describe what you were hearing (and didn't like) about the deltas and what you replaced them with?


Re: Seven pi questions [message #43858 is a reply to message #43846] Tue, 03 February 2004 15:05 Go to previous messageGo to previous message
GrantMarshall is currently offline  GrantMarshall
Messages: 77
Registered: May 2009
Viscount

I made the mistake (or maybe not) of going to the Lima Ohio high efficiency show and rotating through about 40 rooms of just great systems. They included Bruce Edgars Titans and all kinds of other BEAUTIFUL set ups. As you went from room to room the tube amps were getting swapped for other tube amps. The music was very good. A lot of the DIY crowd was there.

I came home and listened to my 2 way Pi 7's with the Delta 15's in them. Not a fair comparison at all. There was some good money in some of the systems I had been listening to, forget the sweat equity, but the ears don't know about a price tag, they just listen to the sound.

I replaced the 2 way with the 3 way Pi 7 option (my own version with Waynes advice). I kept the Emminence driver to handle 3500+, put in a cone midrange in a small sealed cabinet on top of the regular Pi 7 to handle 400-3500, and use a Klipsch K-43 in the bottom end. I have them bi-amped with an EL34 on the top/mid and an old Luxman on the bottom. L-pads help even out the mid/high efficiency difference. I'm getting to where I'm quite happy with my system but still have to do some veneer work, etc.

What I didn't like about the Deltas was that they just weren't clean sound. I haven't used the JBL's or the higher end Emminence (there are much nicer than the Delta's).

What I like about the Pi 7's is what I think most people refer to as dynamics. The music is a lot busier than a lot of speakers. Choose an instument to listen to and you can listen to it. You can HEAR the drums getting BEAT. It's not just a little sound lost in the music, somebody is pounding on those suckers. That's something the horns do without a lot of power. This isn't what you'd call late night listening. There is definite imaging with the corner horns in a 3 way set up.

One thing to be aware of is the size of the Pi 7's. There is a huge difference between the Theatre and other choices.

Once you start playing/tweaking the system is a hobby as much as listening to the music. You'll find the support on this forum is great. WARNING: This hobby is addictive !!!!

Best wishes.


Grant.




Previous Topic: My beloved Pi 7's for sale along with VOTT's
Next Topic: JBL 2220 H
Goto Forum:
  


Current Time: Wed Nov 27 10:20:37 CST 2024

Sponsoring Organizations

DIY Audio Projects
DIY Audio Projects
OddWatt Audio
OddWatt Audio
Pi Speakers
Pi Speakers
Prosound Shootout
Prosound Shootout
Miller Audio
Miller Audio
Tubes For Amps
TubesForAmps.com

Lone Star Audiofest