I would say the tool you choose will depend on the purpose. For instance, an audio designer will use a measurement to evaluate the performance of a particular equipment, whereas a maintenance engineer will be more interested in detecting any defects. The majority of us probably use this for health and safety purposes. I would invest some money to get a good measurement tool.
Haven't heard of good quality stuff being available for free for a long time. I believe that you have to incur some cost in order to get a good tool. I think I've heard of the WTPro. Is it Woofer Tester Pro in full?
Wayne Parham Messages: 18786 Registered: January 2001
Illuminati (33rd Degree)
That's right - WTPro is made by Smith & Larson, the same company that made the original Woofer Tester. But WTPro is much more full-featured, including the ability to make acoustic measurements in addition to the basic electro-mechanical parameter measurements. And the thing I really like about it is the Interactive Crossover Designer.
The ICD provides a mechanism to use a Spice model to create a digital filter. What this does it to allow a designer to enter the Spice model of a passive crossover and then to measure a loudspeaker using this digital representation of the crossover. The benefit is that crossover changes can be realized immediately, during measurements, simply by changing values in the Spice model.
I've done several designs with the ICD and it has proven to be 100% accurate. I am able to "dial-in" my crossovers, fine-tuning the on-axis and polar response using the ICD. When I am happy with the ICD measurements, I then build a physical crossover and measure again. It is an extremely useful design tool.
See a write-up of the ICD design process at the link below. It includes a link to a video where you can see the WTPro in action.
Posting Rules
Members
Search
Help
Register
Login
Get a T-Shirt!
