I don't think that's fair. I respect Jim Griffin a great deal and I also respect Earl Geddes a great deal. You may not agree with Geddes comments, but it isn't like he said "arrays suck." Dr. Geddes simply made the statement that he doesn't see an advantage in small rooms. Maybe he means rooms that are too small for the array. With a little more specificity, you might find you actually agree with him.In his book, Audio Transducers, Geddes investigates arrays and describes their directivity and acoustic behavior. So it isn't as if he were new to these concepts.