| Cabinet Doors, 3Pi changes and Plan Request [message #87618] |
Fri, 30 March 2018 16:54  |
joshua43214
Messages: 35
Registered: October 2016
Location: USA
|
Baron |
|
|
Hello all,
I have several different topics I would like some help with. I am going to order 6Pi's in a couple of weeks, and I plan to use a 3Pi as a center channel.
My first question is in regards to the dimensions of the 3Pi. The 6Pi's will flank a fireplace that I have never used in 23 years of ownership. It occurred to me that I could tuck the 3Pi back into the fire box. My fire box is tiny and measures 21w x 23h x 14d. This is fairly close to the side profile of the 3Pi. I am wondering if I could make the speaker shorter and put the extra volume on the side along with the drivers and horn.
My second question is in regards to the bookshelves that flank the fireplace. I am going to replace the freestanding shelves that came with the house with proper built-ins with doors.
I am worried about the doors themselves resonating, and would like some advice on construction materials. The walls are lathe and plaster.
I see two options, sliding doors (which are not a perfect fit style wise) and flush mounted hinges.
Hinges are by far the simpler solution since I can use latches that will pull the doors firmly closed to prevent any rattles. The down side is the doors can not be of equal width if I want to be able to open the door closest to the fireplace with out moving the speaker, but I am willing to have unequal doors.
I do plan to put the speaker on wheels, but I also plan to store CD's and movies in the book shelves, so having easy access to the shelves is important. Sliding doors will require me finding and fabricating some solution to hold them rigid so they do not rattle.
The last option is not to use doors at all, but I think that defeats the purpose of using a corner horn in the first place. Please correct me if I am wrong on this point.
Any thoughts on door materials? Is raised panel construction ok? Or do I have to use flat panels like yucky Ikea stuff in my Arts and Crafts bungalow?
The ideal thing to match the house would be oak doors with 6 or 8 glass panels, next best is 2 (or even 1) oak raised panels, last would be oak veneered plat panel. Oak raised panels must be free floating, and can be challenging to make so they do not rattle during the winter. Glass panels can be rigidly glazed, but will make any damping materials visible unless they are almost opaque (opaque = very expensive).
Flat panels have the benefit that I can veneer over anything solid enough to not get permanently crushed in my veneer press.
My intuition says that the contours of raised panels are OK, since the wavelengths coming out of the bass box will pass right over them, but my understanding is that the bass driver does share a fair bit of the low-midrange that could be affected.
Any thoughts on what doors will do? Should they be backed with damping material? If so, what is good that is still thin? Are glass panels just a nightmare problem?
I am a very competent furniture maker (formerly a professional), and a competent hobby machinist. I have two shops full of woodworking and metal working machinery. So basically, nothing is out of the question provided it is worth the hassle.
Lastly, Wayne, please email me plans for the 2Pi tower and the 3Pi please.
Thank you all in advance
-Josh
|
|
|
|
| Re: Cabinet Doors, 3Pi changes and Plan Request [message #87626 is a reply to message #87618] |
Sun, 01 April 2018 11:33  |
 |
Wayne Parham
Messages: 18789
Registered: January 2001
|
Illuminati (33rd Degree) |
|
|
You've got mail!
As for the cabinet and doors, I think you understand the issues well, and you'll just have to investigate the situation using the knowledge you already have. As you mentioned, the two main things are acoustic size of the discontinuity and damping of the panels.
Where a discontinuity is acoustically small, it is inconsequential. This may make the shelves a non-issue for you, because bass wavelengths are long. I often find that adjacent bookshelves are acoustically invisible.
As for the possibility of doors, they just need to be free from vibration and panel resonance. Probably all you'll need is rubber stoppers to prevent them from buzzing when they're closed.
Onto the topic of modifications, I would suggest scanning the forum for posts on mods. The last five articles in the "Cabinet Design" section in the π Speakers FAQ also discuss the issues you might encounter.
In a nutshell, some designs are more easily modified than others with confidence that there won't be adverse effects. Subwoofers, for example, usually have cabinets that are acoustically small so dimensional changes are usually inconsequential because standing waves cannot develop inside. But large full-range speakers are exactly the opposite. You have to assume standing waves will be present, so the shape and position of things are important. The bottom line is I'd suggest performing acoustical measurements to validate any changes you make on the two π tower, three π or four π loudspeakers.
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Re: Cabinet Doors, 3Pi changes and Plan Request [message #87721 is a reply to message #87698] |
Fri, 06 April 2018 09:48 |
|
Wayne Parham
Messages: 18789
Registered: January 2001
|
Illuminati (33rd Degree) |
|
|
Thanks for your order, Josh. We're working on it now.
Also, I appreciate your offer for the CAD drawings, but we already have CAD drawings and even CNC code for some of the more complex models and parts. We don't provide those drawings or G-code because we don't want to encourage third-party flat-pack builders. There have been a few unapproved businesses that have sold flat-pack kits for our models, with one of the most aggressive being just a few years back. They usually start off offering to build cabinets or flat-pack kits as a favor or limited service, but then gradually transition to a full-fledged manufacturing operation.
We provide flat-pack kits for the more complicated horns, and will offer flat-pack kits for all models by the end of the year. This is something I've vacillated on over the years, because I've usually suggested to people that local builders do the work. Mos of the cabinets are simple to build, and the cost of shipping large cabinets is quite expensive, so my thinking was the savings could allow the builder to afford a high-quality finish or just put cash in their pockets. But still, many would like a flat pack offering, and third-parties seem to always try to fill the void. So we'll soon be offering flat-pack kits in addition to the existing kit offerings.
|
|
|
|
Posting Rules
Members
Search
Help
Register
Login
Get a T-Shirt!
