I came across a discussion here that was drawing comparisons between a vinyl and CD. Apparently, vinyl is better than CD in more than one ways. I was shocked after reading the whole thing. Do you agree?
gofar99 Messages: 1947 Registered: May 2010 Location: Southern Arizona
Illuminati (5th Degree)
Hi, I could ask in turn ...is this a trick question? Both are excellent in different ways. I prefer vinyl, but also have an extensive collection of CDs. CDs are quieter (not so much so that it really matters compared to a good vinyl play back system). CDs are consistent. If it sounded good today it will sound the same tomorrow. They are more durable. Vinyl tends to seem (IMO) to have a more natural sound. I find that CDs tend to be less relaxing to listen to (YMMV). The obvious question is...the player I use sub standard? No one would ever define an OPPO SE that way.
Now the second question that was not asked is ...is digital superior to analog? IMO yes. The current hi-res digital (not CD) recordings are probably the best recordings ever made. I suspect that they will be the music of the future. However there is a lot of material on vinyl that will never be moved to digital and if it is....it will have the limitations of the original analog system. So in general...I figure that everyone should listen to what they like on the medium they like and not worry much about the format.
Wayne Parham Messages: 18783 Registered: January 2001
Illuminati (33rd Degree)
I agree with you Bruce, 100%. I have some excellent quality vinyl that sounds wonderful. Particularly the half-speed masters. But the BluRay audio I have definitely gives it competition. And since the BluRays are so consistent and durable, I like them better. Not to mention they include video content as well.
Ditto to all of the above. Sound quality plus preference. Also, I think about the logistics of vinyl vs. CDs. Storage space and convenience of travel make CDs the preferred medium in many cases.
I love vinyl for the sound and some of the extras they threw onto records when they were trying to sell more, like split grooves. However while I prefer the sound, there is no doubt that CDs and MP3s are easier to manage, store, and listen to. One scratch on a record and listening to it requires making a digital version and a hefty cleanup job, but then I have had a couple of CDs shatter and the tracks on them are gone for good.
Keven Messages: 40 Registered: April 2017 Location: New York
Baron
This is a matter opinion, though both sides of the argument bring up very valid points. I personally think that CDs are better but that's because I have more experience with them than vinyl.
Great discussions here but then my question would be, are CDs more durable in comparison to vinyl? I wouldn't think so. As Bruce mentions, audio enthusiasts should worry (too much) about the format; most people have never set their eyes on a vinyl record.
Frankie Messages: 10 Registered: September 2017 Location: DC
Chancellor
This is such a tough call because they are both awesome in their own ways. I think vinyls are really cool, retro and sound great. They're definitely more durable. However, there's just no comparison when it comes to which one is more convenient. I really enjoyed reading that article!
mamoss, I don't really think they're more durable than vinyl.
This whole discussion got me thinking about the challenges faced when trying to convert vinyl to mp3. Some quality is definitely lost, right? This is a tricky question, considering that they both have their strong points. We cant completely throw away anything's that's analog, right?
gofar99 Messages: 1947 Registered: May 2010 Location: Southern Arizona
Illuminati (5th Degree)
Hi, The question of durability is uncertain. CDs and DVDs are less sensitive to physical damage but there are some concerns that the substrate they use for the data might not last. I can't verify that as all my earliest CDs play just fine. Even burned one are fine. So that aspect may not be factual. LPs however can be damaged in several ways. Dropped and cracked, warped by heat and the obvious one...scratched. Even playing them on marginal turntables or with worn stylus can damage them. Care is essential for their longevity. That said I have several that are over 50 years old and they are just fine. I do take care in their playing (cleaning is good too but an entirely different topic) and my equipment is very high quality. It is hard to define durability from a sound basis. In theory a digital recording will play the same forever. LPs do exhibit some wear, but with good gear it is very minimal and thousands of plays without significant degradation are possible. Generally I find a much bigger issue in how well the recording was made, mastered and produced. Great music poorly recorded etc will sound bad no matter what the medium. Great music well recorded etc and played on low fi gear will sound low-fi.
Posting Rules
Members
Search
Help
Register
Login
Get a T-Shirt!
