Horns Length, Frequency Wave Lengths, And, All That Good Stuff [message #38709] |
Fri, 18 October 2002 08:04 |
Elliot Thompson
Messages: 5 Registered: May 2009
|
Esquire |
|
|
Greetings! I was wondering in reference to folded horns that are 4 feet. Would length of the horn (4 foot) produce the wavelength somewhere around 200Hz? If not, how can you measure the horns length to determine the frequency? Also, if this box was a 4 cubic foot enclosure, what would that be in horns length? (feet) Thank you, Elliot
|
|
|
Re: Horns Length, Frequency Wave Lengths, And, All That Good Stuff [message #38719 is a reply to message #38709] |
Fri, 18 October 2002 13:39 |
|
Wayne Parham
Messages: 18784 Registered: January 2001
|
Illuminati (33rd Degree) |
|
|
Hi Elliot! Risking oversimplification, a horn's performance is determined by its length, its flare shape, its mouth area, its throat area and its radiating diaphhragm, motor and compression. The lowest frequency is determined by its length, which is 1/4 wavelength. The highest frequency is determined by radiator mass and motor strength. Efficiency is determined by motor strength and compression and by its ability to limit directionality and focus the sound with flare size and shape. The shape and ratio of throat to mouth area set the horn's response curve, and small mouths usually result in response curves with ripples unless the horn radiates into fractional space, like from ground planes (2π steradians), wall/ground junctions (π steradians) or room corners (π/2 steradians). Wayne
|
|
|
questions.......................... [message #38726 is a reply to message #38719] |
Fri, 18 October 2002 22:54 |
|
How does the ear perceive a low frequency note when the wavelength is so large and you are standing next to the subwoofer?I've heard so many debates, ie, some say you can't hear a 20hz - 50hz note inside the car but your neighbors can hear the bass due to the large wavelength. Other person will say that good headphones can produce 20hz - 50hz notes and you can hear it. Some also say that in order to hear those low frequencies in a movie theater, one should sit in back. When we hear low frequencies up close, do we really hear the actual frequency in question coming from the woofer or do we hear the actually frequency after the wave has completed the cycle in which case it has bounced around the room for a bit ? My personal experience is this. If I hear a car playing low bass notes from a distance, I don't hear those same low notes if I sit inside the car, but you do feel the pressure. Are you just feeling the pressure, but not hearing the actual low frequencies ? In movie theaters I also hear much lower bass if I sit in the back vs. sitting in front in which case I hear mostly tweeters. Same theater I go to and they have the subs up front. When I put headphones on and listen to a 40hz-50hz tone, I do hear something like fluttering. Am I really hearing the true 40hz tone or am I hearing something else ?
|
|
|
|
Re: questions.......................... [message #38728 is a reply to message #38726] |
Sat, 19 October 2002 04:01 |
mollecon
Messages: 203 Registered: May 2009
|
Master |
|
|
Wayne is right - at frequencies that have long wavelength compared to the room dimensions the whole room is pressurised instead of the waves spreading in a normal fashion. But the idea of low frequencies not being audible in small rooms is quite a persistant one it seems. But think of it; you mentioned headphones yourself - strictly speaking, the only room/dimension they have is the length from the headphone diaphragm to the eardrum - since that distance is less than an inch it would mean that you could only hear frequencies well above 10kHz on a pair of headphones! Which is quite absurd of course. Your listening experience with the headphones at the 40 Hz note doesn't surprise me - most headphones, regardless of price & what the manufacturer claims don't give out much below 100 Hz or so. So if you turned up the volume in the hope of hearing those 40 Hz you most likely overloaded them - which is probably what you heard. Concerning your other questions: When you're outside a car, you don't hear the rest of the music so loud - hence the bass become more appearant. When you're in the car, the notes at higher frequencies will tend to mask the bass. So, you feel the bass more than actually hearing it - especially in a listening environment as resonant (& leaky!) as a car. The 'masking' effect can to a degree explain your theater experience too - higher fequencies tend to loose their power at distance faster than the lower ones. So when you move back from the front/side speakers, the level of bass seems to rise relative to the rest. Furthermore, if you sit close to room bounderies (walls) like way back in the theater certain bass notes will be amplified due to standing wave modes & the higher pressure close to the walls. You can experience exactly the same at home - try turning your hifi up a bit & move about in the room; if you place your head (& thereby ears!) close to a wall, especially the wall opposite the speakers I bet you'll be able to hear the rise in bass level. OK - the whole question of bass & room behaviour is far more complicated than this, but this answer has become too long already - hope it helped a bit. Regards, Peter.
|
|
|
|
Non sequitur [message #38732 is a reply to message #38729] |
Sat, 19 October 2002 10:10 |
|
Wayne Parham
Messages: 18784 Registered: January 2001
|
Illuminati (33rd Degree) |
|
|
Hello Elliot! The volume of a horn is not a direct indicator of its length. It can be very long and narrow, very wide but short or somewhere in between. Wayne
|
|
|
Rooms, headphones, bass................. [message #38735 is a reply to message #38726] |
Sat, 19 October 2002 10:34 |
mikebake
Messages: 243 Registered: May 2009
|
Grand Master |
|
|
From a post I made on the JBL forum, on the same issue So I am searching for more insight on the headphone issue, and I found this.........it suggests that we CAN hear low bass from headphones, which doesn't apparently mean that it is producing a 30 foot wave, or at least not with any volume...............? We are hearing the compressions and rarefecations, and not the whole wavelength at once......? This is an excerpt from a copyrighted article by Doug Blackburn on www.soundstage.com The entire article is at the link below and was rather interesting. I suggest that you guys may want to read it and see what you think! "Twenty-five Hertz waves in air are twice as long as 50Hz -- 44 to 48 feet. And 20Hz, the lowest frequency we’re supposed to be able to hear, would clock in around 55 to 59 feet long. Do you need a room with at least one 60-foot dimension in it to hear a real 20Hz in the room? No. Your ears actually pick up sound in a different way, reacting to the compressions and rarefactions that happen in the air as the sound propagates though the room. Twenty Hertz creates 20 compressions and rarefactions per second and your ear will pick that up even if you are listening to headphones that respond to frequencies that low. Otherwise your ear canal would have to be 60 feet long -- we would look rather odd if our heads were 60 feet wide." The rest of the article, dealing with bass reproduction, is here http://www.soundstage.com/maxdb/maxdb021999.htm
|
|
|
|