Posted by akhilesh [ 129.244.120.64 ] on August 04, 2005 at 12:35:46:
In Reply to: hornets nest posted by hurdy_gurdyman on August 02, 2005 at 10:49:02:
It's a good thread, guys. I believe all of us learn when two knowledgeable people like Martin & Ed exhange their opinions and views and argue on a public forum. Clearly they have different views on some things (though I am not sure their views are ALL that different). Ed approaches design from a bottom up fashion (build, test, build, test), while MArtin is top-down (design, test, design, test). At least that's my opinion. Both guys are very experienced and knowledgeable, and I think agree on the basics of driver behavior.
While there was borderline hostility, I am glad we are over that. The knowledge you both have is MUCH too valuable to distort with name calling, or as Wayne says: my speaker sounds better than your speaker.
It would be great if both of you could ship your speakers here (and yourselves as well of course, if possible!) at the next GPAF, so we can have a nice listen and post reviews on the speakers that are a product of your methodologies. That would be fun and would probably benefit you both as well in the evolution of your speakers.
Tulsa is centrally located. Shippiing speakers is not that expensive.
I'm sure we can find a comparo room for you guys at the next GPAF, if all you do is ship the speakers.
What say you?
-akhilesh
[ SingleDriverSpeakers Forum ] [ Help ]