An even shorter comment

In Reply to: A short comment. posted by mollecon on September 12, 2003 at 20:35:28:

Hey Mollecon,
Ok then. Say we had the DPL12 woofer then. A PiAligned cabinet produces a -3db point of 25Hz with this woofer in a 58L, 15Hz tuned box (pialign). A vented cabinet of 140L tuned to 15Hz with this woofer produces a -3db point of a much lower 16Hz. Would the PiAligned cabinet, or the larger cabinet with deeper -3db point (both same 15Hz Fb though) produce least overring?
My idea is just a little confused. The PiAligned box is tuned 15Hz, but -3db point is 25Hz, and at its 15Hz Fb, its about -10db down. But the larger cabinet with same tuning is -3db at its Fb. The larger cabinet, as it seems, offers more damping and less ringing. But on the smaller cabinet, resonance is -10db down so would that not mean ringing is even less in the smaller box because resonance itself is attenuated so greatly compared to the larger box?
Thanks!
Adrian

Follow Ups:

Choices and optimizations - Wayne Parham 00:28:25 09/13/03 (16)
- Re: Choices and optimizations - Adrian Mack 02:25:13 09/13/03 (15)
  - Almost... - mollecon 17:33:56 09/13/03 (0)
  - Re: Choices and optimizations - Wayne Parham 04:39:19 09/13/03 (13)
    - Cool. - Adrian Mack 09:35:30 09/13/03 (12)
      - Re: Cool. - Wayne Parham 18:22:00 09/13/03 (11)
        
        Re: Cool. - Adrian Mack 01:45:30 09/14/03 (10)
        
        Sowy for budging in again - mollecon 17:39:49 09/14/03 (3)
        
        Horn phase - Wayne Parham 03:22:19 09/15/03 (2)
        
        Re: Horn phase - Adrian Mack 07:32:12 09/15/03 (1)
        
        Re: Horn phase - Wayne Parham 08:54:06 09/15/03 (0)
        
        Re: Cool. - Wayne Parham 02:37:44 09/14/03 (5)
        
        Re: Cool. - Adrian Mack 02:22:16 09/15/03 (4)
        
        Ah, I figured most of it out - Adrian Mack 02:40:04 09/15/03 (3)
        
        Pneumatic loading - Wayne Parham 08:14:56 09/15/03 (2)
        
        Re: Pneumatic loading - Adrian Mack 09:14:36 09/15/03 (1)
        
        Re: Pneumatic loading - Wayne Parham 09:44:44 09/15/03 (0)