Posted by jeff mai on May 13, 2003 at 05:28:16

Thanks for the response below, Wayne.

I've attached a graph comparing an intriguing looking Beyma 12K200 woofer to a JBL 2206H woofer in a Pi-Aligned cabinet. The T/S parms for the Beyma unit are:

Fs = 35Hz
Re = 6.2 ohms
Qms = 11.17
Qes = 0.229
Qts = 0.225
Vas = 160 liters
Cms = 383 um / N
Rms = 1 kg / s
n0 = 2.9%
Sd = 0.053 m^2
Xmax = 4.5 mm
Le = 0.8 mH

I also compared the Beyma unit in a "shelved" type alignment you mentioned in the previous thread. I think the Beyma compares well to the JBL, though it's distortion figures and build quality are certainly not going to match the JBL. Comments?

I guess my main questions are:

How realistically will these graphs represent the true frequency response? And, which sort of alignment is likely to give best in room response? And if the answer to the previous question is "it depends on the room" is it worthwhile trying to tailor the alignment to the room?

Anyone feel free to chime in.

Thanks,

Jeff Mai

• Re: Woofer / alignment comparison... - Scholl 08:43:20 05/20/03 (0)
• Re: Woofer / alignment comparison... - Wayne Parham 13:39:43 05/13/03 (7)
  • OK, so I've since learned... - jeff mai 04:34:03 05/14/03 (6)
    • Mechanical resonance of speakers - Wayne Parham 04:45:33 05/14/03 (5)
      • Re: Mechanical resonance of speakers - jeff mai 05:14:45 05/14/03 (4)
        • Basically, yes, but... - mollecon 13:15:58 05/14/03 (3)
          • Frequencies of interest - Wayne Parham 13:53:38 05/14/03 (2)
            • Excursion damping bandwidth? - mollecon 14:43:06 05/14/03 (1)
              • Re: Excursion damping bandwidth? - Wayne Parham 16:36:42 05/14/03 (0)